Lawsuit alleges discrimination in Cleveland Fire Department

December 11, 2023

Two women challenge physical fitness test standards

Two women, including a current firefighter, have initiated legal action against the City of Cleveland, alleging discrimination in the fire department’s hiring practices.

Yolanda McKay, a firefighter with the department, and Christine Scott, a candidate who was not hired, filed the lawsuit following their experiences with the department’s physical fitness test.

Background of the lawsuit

McKay, who was eventually hired in 2022, claims she was initially passed over in 2017 due to the test.

Scott, who also took the test in 2017, was not chosen for the position.

Their lawsuit, filed in federal court, seeks an order for Scott’s hiring, back pay, and seniority for both plaintiffs dating back to 2017.

City’s response and EEOC findings

The city spokesperson, Tyler Sinclair, stated that Cleveland is reviewing the lawsuit to determine the appropriate response, affirming the city’s commitment to non-discrimination laws.

This lawsuit follows the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)’s findings that the fire department’s physical agility test had discriminated against women for years, impacting the department’s ability to hire women.

Statistical overview

At the end of the previous year, only 14 of Cleveland’s 778 firefighters were women, highlighting the gender disparity in the department​​.

FSJA Comment

The lawsuit against the Cleveland Fire Department underscores a longstanding issue in fire departments across the United States: gender disparity and potential discrimination in hiring practices.

The case brings to light the challenges women face in traditionally male-dominated fields, particularly in roles requiring physical fitness tests.

The implications of the lawsuit extend beyond Cleveland, as it may prompt other fire departments to re-evaluate their hiring processes and physical fitness standards to ensure they are fair and do not inadvertently discriminate against women or other groups.

The shift in Cleveland’s physical fitness test, prompted by the EEOC’s findings, represents a significant move towards addressing these disparities.

However, the fact that only 14 of 778 firefighters in the city are women, as of last year, indicates that more work is needed to achieve gender balance and equality in the field.

This lawsuit could potentially serve as a catalyst for broader changes in the fire service industry, promoting inclusivity and equal opportunities for all candidates, regardless of gender.

Read Next

Subscribe Now